I take strong issue with John’s Nov. 5 column, “Recent Oregon school shooting renews predictable gun debate.” In it, he vented about the tragic school shooting at Silver Rail Elementary School in Bend, Oregon, on Oct. 15.

In a too-familiar pattern, an angry 16-year-old boy—a former special-needs student at that same school—opened fire in his old classroom. He’d killed three young children and their 25-year-old teacher before another teacher threw her cellphone at him and tackled him. Another child was severely wounded; a teaching assistant had her arm nearly severed by gunfire. Both survived.

The shooter discharged 15 rounds, with another 44 rounds ready to fire.

Thankfully, this carnage was ultimately stopped by Kaylub Giamanco, a 37-year-old father whose children attended Silver Rail, but not before the terrible toll of bloodshed had been inflicted on this school, on the community of Bend, and on our nation’s soul.

Those are the cold facts about this school shooting. Every such school shooting has similarly cold facts, except that in this case Mr. Giamanco happened to be at the right place at the right time, with the right weapon and the skill to use it.

According to a CNN analysis, the Bend, Oregon incident was the 52nd school shooting over the first 41 weeks of 2026, from Jan. 1 through Oct. 15. Since that date, chances are high that the nation has already seen at least two more school shootings.

The threat of firearms in our schools is even more pervasive, according to IntelliSee, an AI video surveillance platform that monitors live camera feeds to flag safety threats to schools. IntelliSee reports that in 2025, there were at least 233 school shootings in the United States.

In how many of these cases was the shooter stopped by armed parents, staff, or a bystander? John Donegan’s column implicitly contradicts the fact that “the classic ‘good guy with a gun’ situation … supposedly never occurs.”

It is a rare event when a “good guy with a gun” halts an active school shooting: Over the last 25 years, more than 630 cases of “active attack” incidents were studied by the Advanced Law Enforcement Rapid Response Training Center at Texas State University. Of these, fewer than 5 percent ended when armed civilians shot the attacker.

Those are the facts, but let’s now deal directly with the grief that we all should feel in our hearts.

Notably absent from John’s column is any expression of sympathy for those who died in any of these dreadful school shootings taking place every week in America.

Donegan throws out the phrase “gun-hating liberal” as an epithet to inflame readers. I count myself as a strong liberal, but do I hate guns?

No, of course not.

Guns have a useful place if confined to a “well-regulated militia” as the Second Amendment intended. The Supreme Court has effectively nullified that constitutional check on the rampant rise of gun ownership. As a result, far too many people have access to this arsenal of mass destruction when they have no legitimate business with a gun.

I don’t hate guns, but as Thomas Jefferson famously said, “I have sworn upon the altar of God eternal hostility against every form of tyranny over the mind of man.” Our national infatuation with guns, an obsession that’s penetrated so many of our nation’s best minds, is a form of tyranny.

And neither do I hate the people who genuinely love and respect the power of firearms. I will, however, eternally hate the “gun culture” that has infected so many people who contribute to this culture with seemingly no remorse for its consequences.

John Ashbaugh writes to the Sun from San Luis Obispo. Respond with an opinion of your own sent to letters@santamariasun.com.

AI is coming; who will protect the public interest?

Because Truth Matters: Invest in Award-Winning Journalism

Dedicated reporters, in-depth investigations - real news costs. Donate to the Sun's journalism fund and keep independent reporting alive.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *