BETWEEN ROCK MUSIC AND A HARD PLACE: In his recent resignation letter to the city of Guadalupe, former Police Chief Michael Cash (center) recalled some of his favorite career accomplishments, including his work coordinating with One805—Kevin Costner’
BETWEEN ROCK MUSIC AND A HARD PLACE: In his recent resignation letter to the city of Guadalupe, former Police Chief Michael Cash (center) recalled some of his favorite career accomplishments, including his work coordinating with One805—Kevin Costner’s nonprofit dedicated to supporting first responders—to receive grant funding over the past eight years. Cash attended a One805 charity concert in late September. Credit: Courtesy photo by Heidi Martin

Nov. 11 marked Michael Cash’s last day as Guadalupe’s public safety director after holding the title—the top rank jointly leading the city’s police and fire departments—for eight years.

He informed the City Council he was resigning on Nov. 10, shortly before the start of a closed session hearing.

That hearing was scheduled to discuss formal allegations against Cash, including that he allegedly misused his city purchasing credentials for “discretionary spending during a period of identified city financial constraints,” City Attorney Philip Sinco told the council.

Sinco said that under Brown Act rules, the council couldn’t be briefed about these issues prior to the closed session item labeled: “Public employee discipline/dismissal/release.”

“The City Council is in an unusual position of being the supervisor of an employee,” Sinco said. “The Brown Act makes it very difficult to provide information to a supervisor that a supervisor has to have in order to make informed personnel decisions. And that’s the purpose of the closed session tonight.”

As a condition to holding a closed session “on specific complaints or charges brought against an employee by another person or employee,” however, Sinco said, the employee under scrutiny has the right to respond to the charges in open session.

“Then we go into closed session,” Sinco told the council. “You would do the deliberation in closed session on this information.”

Given notice 24 hours in advance about the closed session hearing, Cash said he made the decision to resign ahead of the hearing to secure a severance pay package—equal to six months’ salary—outlined in his contract.

“The only way that I can protect myself, my family, to get that severance pay is to terminate the contract,” Cash told the council. “What I was told was the council wanted me to move on.”

“No,” Councilmember Whitney Furness replied. “I can say wholeheartedly that the council as a whole has not discussed the dismissal of the chief. I don’t even think that was on our radar. … I’m shocked by this.”

Cash said that during a recent meeting between himself, City Attorney Sinco, and Human Resources Manager Sylvia Estrada, he was told that “the City Council has directed staff to advise me that they want to move in a different direction, and that I need to make a decision … or I could lose out on certain things.”

Sinco later told the council that “the chief’s understanding, with all respect, is not accurate about what’s going on this evening in terms of the procedure.”

At a few points during the council meeting, the two spoke over one another.

“The thing that’s interesting about this hearing is no one brings to me whatever I’m supposed to have done,” Cash said. “So I have to somehow materialize, in my head, whatever I’m going to comment on.”

“I explained this to the chief,” Sinco interjected, “that you haven’t heard the evidence and he hasn’t heard it yet. That’s the whole point. … He can’t complain about not being provided with that since you haven’t been provided with that.”

Following the Nov. 10 meeting, Sinco confirmed to the Sun that while the council took no reportable action during the closed session hearing, the city accepted Cash’s resignation and that Nov. 11 marked his last day.

In his resignation letter to the city, Cash listed various career accomplishments, including how he obtained $100,000 annually in grant monies from One805—Kevin Costner’s nonprofit to support first responders—over the past eight years, totaling to $800,000 to support police and fire department needs.

“I have accomplished everything I have set out to do as I leave as your chief,” Cash wrote. “According to three separate rating agencies, Guadalupe is ranked the second-safest city of its kind in the state of California. … By the grace of God, I have completed my mission. Now, I look forward to dedicating my time to what matters most: being a full-time grandfather, father, and husband.”

Prior to Guadalupe hiring him in 2018, Cash worked for the Southwestern College campus police department in Chula Vista between 2012 and 2017.

In 2014, the department placed him on administrative leave for about two months for accidentally firing his gun in the police locker room. Before resigning in 2017, Cash denied allegations from college leadership that he misused nearly $1 million in campus funds, discovered after an audit found 100-plus mistakes in an annual security report Cash produced.

During public comment prior to Cash’s recent closed session with the Guadalupe City Council, NAACP Santa Maria-Lompoc Branch President Lawanda Lyons-Pruitt spoke in “resolute support” of Cash.

“We are fully aware of your so-called evaluation and the thinly veiled attempt to malign his character and record. We are here tonight to call a spade a spade,” Lyons-Pruitt said. “Under federal law, Chief Cash falls under several protected classes based upon race and age. Do not attempt to undermine … or malign him at the tail end of a very honorable, accomplished, seasoned, and distinguished career.”

Because Truth Matters: Invest in Award-Winning Journalism

Dedicated reporters, in-depth investigations - real news costs. Donate to the Sun's journalism fund and keep independent reporting alive.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *