Ti West (MaXXXine, Pearl, X, In a Valley of Violence) directs screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern’s adaptation of Charles Dickens’ classic 1843 Victorian London novella A Christmas Carol about miserly businessman Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp), who’s taken on a supernatural journey through his past, present, and future for a chance at redemption. (116 min.)
Ebenezer
What’s it rated? PG-13
What’s it worth, Anna? Matinee
What’s it worth, Glen? Full price
Where’s it showing? Regal Edwards RPX Santa Maria,
Movies Lompoc, Regal Edwards Arroyo Grande
Glen: Despite being billed as “A Christmas Carol as you’ve never seen it before,” Ebenezer plays it by-the-book. Sure, we get a bit more Ebenezer backstory—his abandonment at a boarding school until his beloved sister (Imogen Turner) fetches him with assurances that his alcoholic dad is sober (he’s not), a young but doomed love affair with Belle (Ellie Bamber) that breaks his heart. As the Ghost of Christmas Present (a gravitas-filled Tramell Tillman) notes, maybe there’s still a shred of redeemable humanity in Ebenezer, but he’s very hard to love. He’s demanding of his employee Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint); he’s indifferent to his nephew, Fred (Sam Clafin), and Fred’s family, and impoverished people. Throw them all in the poorhouse to work off their debts! What makes the film watchable is West’s deft direction, Checco Varese’s incredibly atmospheric cinematography, and an overall very effective gothic milieu.
Anna: Promoted with the line, “The master of misfits returns” in reference to Depp, I was concerned that Ebenezer would rely too heavily on Depp for character work and that the whole things would end up feeling a bit too much of an all-Depp production, as things he participates in often do. I’m sure there’re plenty of Depp fans out there still, but he’s been timid at dipping his toe back into the world of blockbusters after his televised courtroom drama and Grindelwald dismissal. Luckily West creates a universe with Scrooge in it, not a universe within Scrooge. He was smart to make the miserly man more sympathetic, and while the present-day Ebenezer is cartoonish in moments, Depp’s performance isn’t hollow. It’s difficult to reimagine so well-worn a story, but Christmas spirit does manage to have a heartbeat in this retelling. It’ll be in theaters from now till New Year, I’m sure, and with “No School November” and winter break ahead, there will be plenty of time for the family to catch a bit of Christmas spirit in theaters. Ebenezer might prove the salve needed to remind everyone what the season should be about.
Glen: I used to love almost everything Depp did, but I find him sort of annoying now. He over acts, and he’s too ubiquitous and distinctive to disappear into a role, even under prosthetics and heavy makeup. But everything around him in Ebenezer—his costars, the classic story, the mise-en-scene and attention to detail—shines. I also giggled when Ebenezer gets sucked into his bed, a clear nod to Depp’s very first role in A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) when his character, Glen Lantz, is sucked into the bed before a geyser of blood spurts out. More than a dozen A Christmas Carol adaptations exist. Even the Muppets had a go. Depp aside, this one’s better than most.
Anna: I agree. Just about everyone my age at one time had a bit of an obsession with Depp, but it seems like his star has dimmed, and rightfully so. I do love all things Christmas, however. While I’ll still choose the Muppets over any other adaptation of the classic tale, this one is visually engaging. It moves at a clip that keeps it from feeling tired, and the cast did well at making the story about more than an old, lonely man. The effects of the ghosts and the bed-sucking scene were all very well done, and the lessons learned by Scrooge are certainly needed in our turbulent and money-driven society.
New Times Arts Editor Glen Starkey and freelancer Anna Starkey write Sun Screen. Comment at gstarkey@newtimesslo.com.
This article appears in November 19 – November 26, 2026.

